Digitisation challenges teachers
A recent study conducted by the ZHAW and Swisscom has shown that Swiss schoolteachers see digitisation as an opportunity. The versatility of digital media and promoting digital literacy are considered to be the greatest advantages. Teachers would like more technical and didactic support with digital media though.
In general, secondary school teachers in Switzerland have a positive attitude towards digital media and frequently use digital content in the classroom. Of the teachers who took part in the survey, 80 per cent find digital formats attractive when planning lessons, and 71 per cent believe that using digital media not only conveys subject matter, but also promotes students’ digital literacy. These are some of the findings published in the most recent JAMESfocus report entitled “Digital media in the classroom” (Digitale Medien im Unterricht). For the study, conducted by the ZHAW Media Psychology section and the telecommunications company Swisscom, over 100 secondary school teachers were surveyed on their use of digital media for teaching purposes.
Online research and digital presentations
The vast majority of teachers rate the technical equipment in their schools as fairly good to very good. Special computer and IT rooms, as well as wireless networks for classroom purposes, are now standard in most schools. Approximately three-quarters of the teachers surveyed have laptops or tablets for their lessons. Students in about a fifth of the schools work exclusively on devices they bring from home (“Bring your own device”).
Nearly all teachers frequently use the Internet to gather information for their lessons. In terms of equipment, projectors are the most common electronic device after computers and laptops. The most frequent form of digital and audio-visual content used is television or video clips (61 per cent). Only about a third of teachers regularly use digital texts, such as online articles. Roughly half of all teachers offer their students support or recommendations on using digital media and thus effectively promote “digital learning”. This takes the form of, for example, providing tips on Internet research or digital learning materials. In individual cases, students are explicitly required to complete a task without the help of the Internet.
«It’s important that students not only learn where they can find what information online. They must also develop an awareness of who the information belongs to and how they’re allowed to use it.»
Lilian Suter, media psychologist
Four fifths of the teachers report that their students at least occasionally copy content from the Internet and submit it as their own work, and over a quarter of the teachers say this occurs very often. “It’s important that students not only learn where they can find what information online. They must also develop an awareness of who the information belongs to and how they’re allowed to use it,” says ZHAW media psychologist Lilian Suter.
Great opportunities, but challenges too
Teachers believe the new curriculum module entitled “Media and IT” offers a range of excellent opportunities, while also posing numerous challenges. They say the most positive aspects are related to the many ways digital media can be used, such as, for example, when searching for information or holding presentations. Another advantage is that, by using digital resources, students acquire skills in conducting online searches and in other practical applications, and they learn how to use digital media responsibly. “When digital media is used regularly in the classroom, it’s clear that digital competence is no longer just “nice to have”. At the same time, quite a few teachers are really stretched to their limits,” says Michael In Albon, Youth Media Protection Officer at Swisscom.
Several teachers state that a major challenge lies in how to teach their students such digital competence. They worry about lacking the necessary expertise and fear that acquiring the know-how required will be difficult. For some teachers, finding the right balance of digital media in a lesson also poses a challenge.
Teachers see digital distraction in the classroom as the greatest danger of using digital media. Moreover, 68 per cent of teachers surveyed state that students no longer understand why they should acquire knowledge themselves when information is always available online, and the same percentage of teachers are concerned that adolescents are unable to distinguish facts from fake information. The previous JAMESfocus report published key findings on “fake news” as well as useful tips for dealing with the issue.
Calls for more support
Overall, most teachers surveyed not only have a positive view of digital media, but they are also practised users. Despite this positive self-assessment, however, nearly all respondents wish there was someone at their schools to maintain the technical equipment and to offer quick assistance when problems arise. Over half of all teachers would like support with the use of digital media. “Ideally, teachers would have modern materials that encourage the use of digital media in the classroom and which in turn would support them in fostering their students’ digital literacy,” says Lilian Suter.
Contact
[Translate to english:] ZHAW Departement Angewandte Psychologie, Tel. 058 934 83 18, E-Mail joy.bolli@zhaw.ch
Swisscom AG, Mediendienst, 3050 Bern, Tel. 058 221 98 04, E-Mail media@swisscom.com
JAMES study and JAMESfocus report
The ZHAW JAMES study has been conducted every two years on behalf of the telecommunications company Swisscom since 2010. Over 1000 adolescents, aged between 12 and 19, from the three major language regions in Switzerland are asked about their media behaviour. Using the data collected in the JAMES study, the JAMESfocus series conducts an in-depth analysis of additional aspects. In 2019, a report entitled “Fake News” was also published. The next report focuses on the topic of media consumption and health.
The JAMES focus reports are based on responses given by adolescents and young adults in the JAMES study; the current report, however, is derived from a second survey of 105 teachers at secondary school level, so that they are teaching the age groups surveyed in the JAMES study. Due to its size and structure, the teacher survey is not representative of all Swiss teachers.